Detroit mayoral candidates attack issues and each other during heated debate

Detroit City Council President Mary Sheffield and the Rev. Solomon Kinloch Jr. used their televised debate on Channel 7 to address issues and criticize each other with increasingly personal attacks.

KinlockSheffield

Soloman Kinloch (left) and Mary Sheffield (right) face off in the race for Detroit's next mayor this November

Detroit’s mayoral candidates came out swinging during a debate televised on WXYZ.

Detroit City Council President Mary Sheffield and the Rev. Solomon Kinloch Jr. used the time to both address issues and criticize each other with increasingly personal attacks.

Morning Edition – Detroit Host Pat Batcheller asked WDET’s Quinn Klinefelter about the messages the candidates were sending to voters.

Listen: Detroit mayoral candidates attack issues and each other during heated debate

Quinn Klinefelter, WDET News: They agreed on several core issues. They said Detroiters need better access to affordable housing, more investment in neighborhood communities and additional methods to fight crime and poverty.

Council president Mary Sheffield said she worked with outgoing Mayor Mike Duggan to deliver Detroit from bankruptcy.

But she wants to cut even more red tape to bring new business to the city at a time when federal Covid relief funding is running out.

Detroit City Council President Mary Sheffield: This is a critical moment in Detroit’s recovery where we can move forward with progress or we can gamble with our future with inexperienced leadership.

QK: Reverend Kinloch is a political newcomer. But he says he is well-versed in one of the long-standing complaints in Detroit, that residents in the outer-ring neighborhoods just don’t feel the benefits from the investments made downtown since the city emerged from bankruptcy.

Rev. Solomon Kinloch Jr.: I grew up in the city of Detroit, the westside of Detroit. I know what it means to hear people saying that the city is coming back but it has not reached your block. It has not knocked on your door.

Pat Batcheller, WDET News: Neither Sheffield nor Kinloch are incumbents in this campaign. But Sheffield has served for a dozen years on the City Council. How did that play into the debate?

QK: Kinloch questioned just how effective Sheffield has been on Council.

She touted numerous programs she initiated, especially in regards to affordable housing and fighting crime.

Sheffield also alleged Kinloch did little to use his bully church pulpit to aid those efforts.

MS: He’s been absent on every single public safety initiative in this city. And we do need more than rhetoric and talk and slogans. We need leadership that delivers. I’ve done that and I will continue to do that as mayor.

SK: She keeps talking about what she’s tried, what she’s tried, what she’s tried. Anything that she wants to do as mayor, she could have done it seated at the City Council table the last 12 years. So at the end of the day, why is it that she didn’t do it?

PB: That was only one in a series of contentious exchanges between the two candidates. And they seemed to become more personal as the debate wore on.

QK: Yes. In fact, the two traded accusations about possible corruption in their financial dealings.

Kinloch, who is in effect the challenger of a veteran, if young, incumbent government official, cast Sheffield as someone more interested in headlines and social media posts then residents’ concerns.

SK: The tenor and tone of my opponent tonight reminds people the danger of having individuals who are privileged to sit in these seats of power. When I distributed laptops to ten thousand kids in the community, you were not there. Time out for us to believe that we are supposed to kiss their ring in order to get access to these people. I believe in talking directly to the people.

MS: I’ve done the same thing, pastor, for 12 years. Occupying the Corners (events.) Shoes. Backpacks. We’ve given out thousands of resources to our residents year after year. But we’ve also made meaningful policy changes in this city, fostering an environment of collaboration that has allowed this city to move forward. And we’re doing it with action, not just rhetoric.

PB: Do we have any idea how this is all playing with voters?

QK: We gained a small window on those opinions courtesy of WDET’s Alex McLenon, who was with voters at a debate watch party.

He talked with Detroiter Chiara Clayton, who says she was not a fan of the attacking style of either candidate.

Chiara Clayton: I wish everyone would just stick to the topics and their plan. It’s hard to have a debate, I guess, without some type of personal digs or contentiousness.  But I just want people to stick to their views or what they want to do.

QK: We’ll see if that happens during the joint appearances the candidates have set over the next few weeks.

Trusted, accurate, up-to-date.

WDET strives to make our journalism accessible to everyone. As a public media institution, we maintain our journalistic integrity through independent support from readers like you. If you value WDET as your source of news, music and conversation, please make a gift today.

Donate today »

More election coverage

Author

  • Quinn Klinefelter is a Senior News Editor at 101.9 WDET. In 1996, he was literally on top of the news when he interviewed then-Senator Bob Dole about his presidential campaign and stepped on his feet.